Transparency in Taxation
Structure of the Report
Scope
Method
Personal Income Tax — Description of Tax Provisions
Ontario Non-refundable Tax Credits
Other Ontario Tax Credits
Exemptions, Deductions and Deferrals Shared with the Federal Government
Corporate Tax — Description of Tax Provisions
Corporate Income Tax
Sales and Commodity Tax — Description of Tax Provisions
Retail Sales Tax
The enactment of the Fiscal Transparency and Accountability Act, 2004, represents a major commitment of the Ontario Government to be more open and accountable. Under Section 6 of the Act, the Minister of Finance is required to release a mid-year review of the fiscal plan on or before November 15 of each year, which must include information about the estimated cost of expenditures made through the tax system.
Tax expenditure reporting is an important element of improved fiscal transparency and accountability. This report is the second annual compilation of the estimated cost of Ontario tax provisions.
This report provides estimates of revenue forgone in 2006 with respect to provisions in the following taxes:
Descriptions of each tax provision were provided in the government's first Transparency in Taxation report, presented in Annex III of the 2005 Ontario Economic Outlook and Fiscal Review, Background Papers. Please refer to the 2005 report for the descriptions.
Electronic copies of the 2005 Ontario Economic Outlook and Fiscal Review, Background Papers are available via the Internet at:
www.fin.gov.on.ca/en/budget/fallstatement/2005/05fs-paperce.pdf
or printed copies are available from:
This report includes descriptions only for tax provisions that are new or have been modified since 2005. The descriptions are intended to provide a basic understanding of the provisions and do not replace the relevant legislation or regulations.
Given the absence of a universally accepted definition of a “tax expenditure,” this report continues the broad approach adopted in last year's report of listing estimates of forgone revenue that could potentially be included under a broad-based tax system.
Personal and corporate income tax expenditures identified in this report include tax expenditures shared with the federal government and Ontario-only tax expenditures.
Under a tax collection agreement between Ontario and Canada, the federal government determines the personal income tax base. Ontario has limited policy control over the individual components of taxable income and the associated tax expenditures related to the federally defined tax base.
Ontario currently collects and administers its own corporate income tax. However, on October 6, 2006, Ontario entered into a Memorandum of Agreement with the federal government under which the federal government would collect and administer Ontario's corporate income tax and capital tax, effective for taxation years ending after 2008. (See Annex IV, Corporate Tax Harmonization, for additional details.)
The estimates in this report were developed using the latest available taxation or economic data, forecast to the 2006 calendar year. The data used to estimate the values of the tax provisions come from a variety of sources. Revisions to the underlying data, as well as improvements to the estimation method, may result in changes to the estimated value of a provision in future publications. As well, some tax provision estimates are particularly sensitive to economic conditions or other variables and those values could fluctuate significantly from year to year.
It is important to note that the estimates in this report are not intended to represent the potential revenue gain for the Province if the tax provisions were not in place. Each estimate has been determined separately and in isolation of other factors, such as the economic impact of any change, behavioural responses, the interaction among various tax provisions, or any modifications in policy that might reasonably accompany the change. As a result, the estimates cannot be added together to determine the total cost of a particular group of tax expenditures.
Tax expenditure estimates of less than $1 million are denoted by the letter “s” (small). This report also includes tax provisions for which relevant data from the tax system are not currently available to the Ministry of Finance. Although estimates may not be available, these items are listed to ensure greater accountability and transparency.
Future annual reports will continue to refine Ontario's tax expenditure estimates.
Table 1 provides estimates of tax provisions relating to the Ontario Personal Income Tax system. Business provisions listed here are for unincorporated businesses.
| Tax Provisions | 2006 Estimates 2 ($ Millions) |
|---|---|
| Ontario Non-refundable Tax Credits | |
| Adoption Expense Credit 3 | 1 |
| Age Credit | 230 |
| Amounts Transferred from Spouse | 40 |
| Basic Personal Credit | 4,105 |
| Canada Pension Plan (CPP)/Quebec Pension Plan (QPP) Contributions Credit | 520 |
| Caregiver Credit | 15 |
| Charitable Donations Credit | 520 |
| Disability Credit | 80 |
| Eligible Dependant Credit | 90 |
| Employment Insurance (EI) Premiums Credit | 195 |
| Infirm Dependant Credit | 1 |
| Medical Expense Credit | 105 |
| Ontario Overseas Employment Tax Credit | 5 |
| Pension Income Credit | 90 |
| Spouse or Common-law Partner Credit | 215 |
| Student Loan Interest Credit | 10 |
| Tuition Fee and Education Credits | 310 |
| Ontario Tax Reduction (OTR) | |
| OTR — Basic Reduction | 165 |
| OTR — Reduction for Dependent Children Under 19 | 195 |
| OTR — Reduction for Disabled or Infirm Dependants | 8 |
| OTR — Total | 305 |
| Other Ontario Tax Credits 4 | |
| Ontario Focused Flow-through Share Tax Credit | 2 |
| Ontario Political Contribution Tax Credit | 5 |
| Ontario Property and Sales Tax Credits (OPSTC) | |
| OPSTC — Non-seniors | 460 |
| OPSTC — Seniors 5 | 505 |
| OPSTC — Total 5 | 965 |
| Ontario Labour Sponsored Investment Fund and Employee Ownership Tax Credits | |
| Employee Ownership (EO) Tax Credit | s |
| Labour Sponsored Investment Fund (LSIF) Tax Credit | 20 |
| Research-oriented Investment Fund (ROIF) Tax Credit | 1 |
| Exemptions, Deductions and Deferrals Shared with the Federal Government | |
| Business | |
Items for Which an Estimate is not Available
|
|
| Employment | |
| Deduction for Clergy Residence | 15 |
| Deduction of Home Relocation Loans | s |
| Deduction of Other Employment Expenses | 260 |
| Deduction of Union and Professional Dues | 130 |
| Employee Stock Options | 150 |
| Moving Expense Deduction | 15 |
| Northern Residents' Deductions | 1 |
Items for Which an Estimate is not Available
|
|
| Farming and Fishing | |
Items for Which an Estimate is not Available
|
|
| Investment | |
| $500,000 Lifetime Capital Gains Exemption for Farming or Fishing Property and Small Business Shares | 140 |
| Deduction of Allowable Business Investment Losses | 10 |
| Deduction of Carrying Charges Incurred to Earn Income | 250 |
| Deduction of Resource-related Expenditures | 70 |
| Partial Inclusion of Capital Gains | 525 |
Items for Which an Estimate is not Available
|
|
| Non-taxable Income | |
| Guaranteed Income Supplement and Allowance Benefits | 20 |
| Social Assistance Benefits | 20 |
| Workers' Compensation Benefits | 155 |
Items for Which an Estimate is not Available
|
|
| Special Circumstances | |
| Child Care Expense Deduction | 150 |
| Treatment of Alimony, Maintenance and Child Support Payments | 50 |
Items for Which an Estimate is not Available
|
|
| Tax-deferred Savings | |
| Registered Pension Plans (RPP) — Deduction for Contributions | 565 |
| Registered Retirement Savings Plans (RRSP) — Deduction for Contributions | 1,875 |
Items for Which an Estimate is not Available
|
|
1 Estimates do not include the impact of revenue forgone from personal income tax provisions for trusts, which are taxed as individuals under the Income Tax Act.
2 Estimates are based on 2003 tax-filer data forecast to represent the 2006 taxation year, unless otherwise noted.
Tax-filer data include only those returns assessed within one year of the taxation year.
3 Estimate is based on federal estimates.
4 Estimates are based on tax-sharing statements (TSS) unless otherwise noted.
5 Estimate is based on TSS and the enrichment of the income threshold for senior couples to $23,090 proposed in the 2006 Ontario Budget.
The following Personal Income Tax provisions have changed since 2005.
The non-refundable tax credits listed in the following table are based on amounts that are adjusted for inflation each year. A brief description of these tax provisions is available in the 2005 Ontario Economic Outlook and Fiscal Review, Background Papers.
| Non-refundable Tax Credits | Base Amount | |
|---|---|---|
| 2005 ($) | 2006 ($) | |
| Adoption Expense Credit, maximum claim | 10,000 | 10,220 |
| Age Credit, maximum claim | 4,002 | 4,090 |
| Reduced by 15 per cent of individual's net income in excess of | 29,793 | 30,448 |
| Basic Personal Credit | 8,196 | 8,377 |
| Caregiver Credit, maximum claim | 3,863 | 3,948 |
| Reduced by dependant's net income in excess of | 13,218 | 13,509 |
| Disability Credit | 6,622 | 6,768 |
| Eligible Dependant Credit, maximum claim | 6,960 | 7,113 |
| Reduced by dependant's net income in excess of | 696 | 711 |
| Dependant's net income less than | 7,656 | 7,824 |
| Infirm Dependant Credit, maximum claim | 3,863 | 3,948 |
| Reduced by dependant's net income in excess of | 5,492 | 5,613 |
| Medical Expense Credit | ||
| Qualifying medical expenses in excess of the lesser of three per cent of net income and | 1,856 | 1,896 |
| Qualifying medical expenses of other dependant, maximum claim | 10,000 | 10,220 |
| Pension Income Credit, maximum claim | 1,133 | 1,158 |
| Spouse or Common-law Partner Credit, maximum claim | 6,960 | 7,113 |
| Not exceeding spouse's or common-law partner's net income deducted from | 7,656 | 7,824 |
| Tuition Fee and Education Credits | ||
| Education Credit, full time (per month) | 441 | 451 |
| Education Credit, part time (per month) | 132 | 135 |
| Maximum transfer | 5,667 | 5,792 |
Item for Which an Estimate is not Available
Items for Which an Estimate is not Available
Item for Which an Estimate is not Available
The estimated values of tax provisions in the Ontario Corporate Income Tax, Capital Tax and Mining Tax systems are presented in Table 2.
| Tax Provisions | 2006 Estimates 1 ($ Millions) |
|---|---|
| Corporate Income Tax | |
| Ontario Refundable Tax Credits | |
| Apprenticeship Training Tax Credit 2,3 | 95 |
| Co-operative Education Tax Credit 2,3 | 5 |
| Ontario Book Publishing Tax Credit 4 | 2 |
| Ontario Business Research Institute Tax Credit | 4 |
| Ontario Computer Animation and Special Effects Tax Credit 4 | 7 |
| Ontario Film and Television Tax Credit 4 | 95 |
| Ontario Innovation Tax Credit | 180 |
| Ontario Interactive Digital Media Tax Credit 4 | 8 |
| Ontario Production Services Tax Credit 4 | 40 |
| Ontario Sound Recording Tax Credit 4 | 1 |
| Ontario Deductions and Exemptions | |
| Additional Deduction for Credit Unions | 4 |
| Assets Used to Generate Clean Energy | s |
| Manufacturing and Processing (M&P) and Resource Sector Credit | 255 |
| Non-taxation of the Federal Investment Tax Credit 5 | 200 |
| Ontario Current Cost Adjustment | 5 |
| Ontario Depletion Allowance | s |
| Ontario New Technology Tax Incentive | s |
| Ontario Political Contributions | 1 |
| Ontario Resource Allowance 6 | 80 |
| Small Business Deduction 7 | 900 |
| Exemptions, Deductions and Deferrals Shared with the Federal Government | |
| Allowable Business Investment Losses 8,9 | 5 |
| Deductibility of Charitable Donations 8 | 110 |
| Deductibility of Gifts to the Crown 8 | s |
| Deductibility of Gifts of Cultural Property and Ecologically Sensitive Land 8 | s |
| Deferral of Income for Farmers 8 | s |
| Holdback on Progress Payments to Contractors 8 | 20 |
| Non-taxation of Non-profit Organizations 8 | 100 |
| Partial Inclusion of Capital Gains 8 | 940 |
Items for Which an Estimate is not Available
|
|
| Capital Tax 10 | |
| Capital Tax Deduction | 300 |
| Deferred Mining Exploration and Development Expenses | 6 |
| Deferred Ontario New Technology Tax Incentive and Scientific Research and Experimental Development Costs | s |
| Exemption for Assets Used to Generate Clean Energy | s |
| Exemption for Family Farm Corporations, Family Fishing Corporations, Credit Unions and Other Specified Entities | s |
| Small Business Investment Tax Credit for Financial Institutions | 10 |
Items for Which an Estimate is not Available
|
|
| Mining Tax 11 | |
| Mining Tax Exemption | 8 |
| Mining Tax Holiday for Mines (other than remote mines) | s |
| Mining Tax Holiday for New Remote Mines | s |
| Mining Tax Rate for Remote Mines | s |
| Processing Allowance | 50 |
Items for Which an Estimate is not Available
|
|
1 Estimates are forecast to the 2006 calendar year based on preliminary 2004 Ontario tax administration data, unless otherwise noted. Estimates do not include the revenue impact of corporate income tax expenditures provided to mutual fund corporations.
2 Estimates include the impact of both the corporate and personal income tax provisions.
3 The Apprenticeship Training Tax Credit was announced in the 2004 Ontario Budget. The estimated 2006–07 impact as provided in the Budget was $95 million. Some of the apprenticeship programs previously included under the Co‑operative Education Tax Credit (CETC) were transferred to the new credit. The estimate for the CETC was produced at the time of the 2004 Ontario Budget.
4 The estimates include the impact of the enhancements outlined in the 2005 Ontario Budget and/or the 2006 Ontario Budget.
5 Relating to qualifying Ontario Research and Development expenses.
6 The resource allowance applies to the mining and oil and gas sectors. The estimate is not net of mining taxes and Crown royalties paid.
7 Includes the impact of the Ontario surtax on Canadian-controlled private corporations.
8 Estimates based on assessed 2004 federal tax administration data, allocated to Ontario and forecast to 2006.
9 Estimate could overstate true value as it does not reflect the future reduction in tax revenues that would occur if those losses were instead deducted from future capital gains.
10 Ontario has legislated a plan to eliminate the capital tax by 2012. The capital tax elimination plan is outlined in Annex IV, Corporate Tax Harmonization.
11 Estimates are forecast to the 2006 calendar year based on preliminary 2004 Ontario mining tax administration data.
The following Corporate Income Tax provisions have changed since 2005.
Items for Which an Estimate is not Available
The estimated values of tax provisions relating to sales and commodity taxes, including the Fuel Tax, Gasoline Tax, Land Transfer Tax, Retail Sales Tax and Tobacco Tax, are presented in Table 3.
| Tax Provisions | 2006 Estimates 1 ($ Millions) |
|---|---|
| Fuel Tax | |
| Exemptions/Reduced Rates | |
| Exemption for Biodiesel 2 | s |
| Exemption for Coloured Fuel 3 | 420 |
| Reduced Rate for Railway Diesel 4 | 32 |
| Refunds | |
| Auxiliary Power Take-off Equipment 5 | 6 |
| Gasoline Tax | |
| Exemptions/Reduced Rates | |
| Exemption for Ethanol, Methanol and Natural Gas 6 | 55 |
| Reduced Rate for Aviation Aircraft 7 | 265 |
| Reduced Rate for Propane 7 | 10 |
| Refunds | |
| Auxiliary Power Take-off Equipment 5 | s |
| Aviation Fuel 5 | s |
| Tax-exempt Use in Unlicensed Equipment 5 | 7 |
| Land Transfer Tax | |
| Exemptions | |
| Life Leases 8 | 1 |
| Deferrals and Exemptions for Corporate Reorganizations 5 | 29 |
Items for Which an Estimate is not Available
|
|
| Refunds | |
| Refund for First-time Home Buyers 5 | 33 |
| Retail Sales Tax | |
| Exemptions | |
| 25¢ Coin Pay Phone Calls 8 | 7 |
| Agricultural Goods | 250 |
| Audio Books Purchased by Persons Who Are Legally Blind 8 | 4 |
| Automobile Insurance Premiums 9,10 | 800 |
| Basic Groceries 10 | 1,600 |
| Books, Newspapers and Magazines Sold by Subscription | 375 |
| Children's Car Seats and Booster Seats 10 | 4 |
| Children's Clothing | 130 |
| Commercial Aircraft, Vessels Greater than 1,400 Cubic Metres and Commercial Vessels Less than 1,400 Cubic Metres | 80 |
| Custom Software 11 | 75 |
| Donations to Schools, Colleges and Universities 8 | 6 |
| Educational CD-ROMs and DVDs 8 | 3 |
| Energy | 4,190 |
| Feminine Hygiene Products 10 | 19 |
| Footwear Sold for $30 or Less | 30 |
| Goods Purchased for Use by Fishers and Fur-trappers | s |
| Individual Life and Health Insurance Premiums 12 | 435 |
| Mobile Homes | s |
| Municipal Fire-fighting Equipment | s |
| Prepared Foods Sold for $4 or Less 10 | 230 |
| Prescription Drugs and Medical Supplies | 830 |
| Production Machinery and Equipment | 560 |
| Religious Equipment | 10 |
| Repairs and Replacements Performed Under Warranty 9 | 140 |
| Seedlings | s |
| Services | 9,640 |
| Toll-free Telephone Services 8 | 46 |
| Transient Accommodation 13 | 85 |
| University Research Equipment | 5 |
Items for Which an Estimate is not Available
|
|
| Credits/Rebates | |
| Rebate for Alternative Fuel Vehicles 5 | 4 |
| RST Rebate for Building Materials for Religious, Charitable and Benevolent Organizations 5 | 22 |
| Tax Credit for Fuel Conservation 14 | 5 |
| Temporary Exemption for Destination Marketing Fees 10 | 2 |
| Temporary Rebate for Building Materials Incorporated into Electricity Generating, Qualifying Nuclear and Deep Lake-water Cooling Facilities 5 | s |
| Temporary Rebate for Solar Energy, Wind Energy, Micro Hydro-electric and Geothermal Energy Systems 5 | s |
| Vendor Compensation 15 | 105 |
| Tobacco Tax | |
| Compensation for Tax Collectors 16 | s |
1 Estimates are forecast to the 2006 calendar year based on preliminary 2002 provincial Input–Output tables from Statistics Canada, unless otherwise noted.
2 Based on estimated amount of biodiesel sold in Ontario.
3 Based on returns filed by registered dyers.
4 Forgone revenue estimated as difference from the regular fuel tax rate.
5 Based on refunds filed or rebates/deferrals claimed.
6 Based on estimated ethanol volumes produced in and imported to Ontario.
7 Forgone revenue estimated as difference from the regular gasoline tax rate.
8 Based on the Ontario Budget estimate, when the measure was proposed, projected to 2006.
9 Estimates assume items would be taxed at eight per cent general RST rate.
10 Figure derived from estimated consumer spending.
11 Based on Statistics Canada Computer Software and Related Services Industry Revenue Profile.
12 Based on insurance premiums data provided by the Canadian Life and Health Insurance Association Inc.
13 The RST rate on accommodations is five per cent. Forgone revenue estimated as difference from the regular RST rate of eight per cent.
14 Based on new passenger vehicle sales.
15 Based on returns filed by RST vendors.
16 Based on returns filed by tobacco tax collectors.
The following Sales and Commodity Tax provisions have changed since 2005.
Table 4 provides estimates of tax provisions relating to the Education Property Tax system.
| Tax Provisions | 2006 Estimates 2 ($ Millions) |
|---|---|
| Brownfields Financial Tax Incentive Program 3 | s |
| Charity Rebate | 7 |
| Conservation Land Property Tax Exemption Program | 2 |
| Eligible Convention Centres Exemption | s |
| Farm Property Class Tax Rate Reduction | 65 |
| Farmlands Awaiting Development Sub-class Tax Rate Reduction | s |
| Heritage Property Tax Rebate | s |
| Live Performance Theatres Exemption and Professional Sports Facility Tax Rate Reduction 4 | 2 |
| Managed Forest Tax Incentive Program | 2 |
| Seniors and Persons with Disabilities Property Tax Relief 5 | s |
| Tax Exemptions Under Private Statutes | 6 |
| Vacant Commercial and Industrial Unit Rebate | 30 |
| Vacant Land and Excess Land Sub-class Tax Rate Reduction | 50 |
Items for Which an Estimate is not Available
|
|
1 Expenditures related to provincial land taxes or payments made in lieu of taxes have not been included.
2 Estimates based on 2006 education tax rates, 2006 Assessment Roll, 2004 Municipal Financial Information Returns and municipal tax policies.
3 Effective October 1, 2004, municipalities may pass bylaws cancelling municipal property taxes on eligible brownfields properties. The Province may match the municipal reduction with an education property tax reduction.
4 In 2006, improved information allowed a much more precise estimate of the exemptions given to live performance theatres.
5 Estimate does not include expenditures due to the exemption from taxation on 10 per cent of the assessment of improvements to accommodate seniors and persons with disabilities in newly built homes or the expenditure on such improvements in existing homes.
Table 5 provides an estimate of the tax exemption under the Employer Health Tax system.
| Tax Provision | 2006 estimates ($ Millions) |
|---|---|
| $400,000 Exemption for Private-sector Employers 1 | 760 |
1 Estimate is based on new methodology and 2004 remuneration data forecast to represent the 2006 taxation year.
Table 6 provides an estimate of the 2006 exemption under the Estate Administration Tax system.
| Tax Provision | 2006 estimates ($ Millions) |
|---|---|
| Exemption Where the Value of the Estate Does Not Exceed $1,000 | s |
Table 7 provides an estimate of the tax provision under the Gross Revenue Charge.
| Tax Provision | 2006 Estimates 2 ($ Millions) |
|---|---|
| Gross Revenue Charge 10-year Holiday | s |
1 Expenditure does not include the provincial water rental portion of the GRC.
2 2006 estimate based on 2004 GRC returns.